Simone:
I wish you would come knock on my window
Come into bed and lay with me
We could believe that just for one night
Things were the way they used to be
I wish we could laugh without a reason
When it was really not pretend
Now looking back it makes me wonder
If we could be that way again

Emmalyn:
Cause right now
It feels like this play is gonna burn out
What happened to us?
It's true
Even though you're here, I still miss you
I hope that's something left

If you want this love
Say you won't give up
Take my hand (I can show you if you let me)
Look into my eyes
Let's go back in time
Take a chance
Baby why don't we just press rewind?

Lauren:
Remember the times you sang me love songs?
When they were always out of key
All of my girls thought you were crazy
But you were magical to me
How did it get so complicated?
When did the clouds turn into rain?
Now looking back it makes me wonder
If it could ever be the same?

Natasha:
Cause right now
It feels like this play is gonna burn out
What happened to us?
It's true
Even though you're here, I still miss you
I hope that's something left

If you want this love
Say you won't give up
Take my hand (I can show you if you let me)
Look into my eyes
Let's go back in time
Take a chance
Baby why don't we just press rewind?

Paula:
Ah ha
That first night (turn it back!)
That first kiss (turn it back!)
It just like this (turn it back!)
Ah ha
That first time (turn it back!)
First "I love you" (turn it back!)
I said "me too" (turn it back!)

If you want this love
Say you won't give up
Take my hand (I can show you if you let me)
Look into my eyes
Let's go back in time
Take a chance
Baby why don't we just press rewind?